Is $1,800 for a timing belt on a 2009 Subaru Forester fair?
Short answer
It looks high for a timing belt alone. A full job with the water pump, tensioner and idlers usually runs around $900 to $1,300 at an independent shop, so ask what else is bundled into the $1,800.
The quote, line by line
| Item | Quoted | Our take |
|---|---|---|
| Timing belt replacement | $1,800 | High unless it includes extra work. A kit (belt, water pump, tensioner, idlers) is about $250 to $400 in parts, plus 3.5 to 4.5 hours of labor. |
What a timing belt job should include
On the 2.5 in this Forester, the belt is driven past the water pump, a hydraulic tensioner and several idler pulleys. Those wear out on the same schedule, and getting to them is most of the labor, so a good shop replaces them all at once with a kit. If the water pump isn't on the quote, ask for it. Doing it later means paying for the same labor twice.
Parts for a quality kit are roughly $250 to $400. Labor is usually 3.5 to 4.5 hours. Add coolant and you land around $900 to $1,300 at most independent shops.
Why $1,800 might still make sense
Some shops bundle in the cam and crank seals, the accessory drive belts, a thermostat or spark plugs while they're in there. Those can be worth doing, but they should be listed so you can decide. A one-line $1,800 quote doesn't let you check any of it, so the first step is asking for it itemized.
It's also worth asking whether the belt is due by mileage (Subaru's interval on this engine is about 105,000 miles) or whether something is actually wrong.
Is the car worth it?
If $1,800 is a third of what the car is worth, it's fair to pause. But a fresh timing belt and water pump on a car that's otherwise healthy usually buys years of driving, and at around $1,000 it's an easier call. A second quote for the same itemized job is the cheapest way to know.
What to ask the shop
- Does the $1,800 include the water pump, tensioner and idlers?
- Can you itemize parts and labor?
- Is anything else bundled in, like seals, belts or plugs?
- Is it due by mileage, or did you find a problem?
This is a worked example based on a repair quote someone shared publicly online. It's our general read of that quote, not a formal Quote Guide review, and the price ranges are typical figures that vary by area and vehicle. Your car and your shop may be different.
Got a quote of your own?
Send it in and an ASE-certified mechanic will go through it line by line within 24 hours, with a fair range for each item and what to ask the shop.
Review My Estimate